Why Nearly 75% Of Pandemic Homebuyers Have Regrets & What Has Changed

Why Nearly 75% Of Pandemic Homebuyers Have Regrets & What Has Changed

  • Liz Kroft
  • 02/6/24

In the frenzy of the pandemic-era housing market, many families and individuals eagerly entered the world of homeownership. Flush with savings accumulated during restricted travel and limited entertainment options, coupled with historically low mortgage rates, the allure of owning a home seemed irresistible.

Fast forward to the aftermath, and we're witnessing a significant number of pandemic buyers grappling with regret. According to Anytime Estimate's American Home Buyer Survey released in September 2022, nearly 75% of Americans who purchased homes in the peak of the pandemic have regrets. This buyer's remorse stems from rushed decisions, compromises on crucial elements, and a lack of thorough research.

The Pitfalls of Hasty Decisions

Many pandemic-era buyers found themselves making substantial compromises, particularly in crucial areas such as price and location. In Santa Cruz County, where the median sales price during these years was $1,138,750 for a single-family home, with a staggering 56% paying over asking, the pressure to act quickly led to decisions that didn't align with long-term needs or protections.

Moreover, a staggering 80% of buyers from the survey compromised on their priorities, such as the right location. Some even purchased fixer-uppers or made non-contingent offers without physically seeing the properties. The fervor of the market, with properties selling well above market rate, fueled a 'go, go, go' mentality that resulted in significant - and risky - compromises.

A Lesson in Research and Prioritization

To avoid the pitfalls of regrettable purchases, it's essential to conduct thorough research and establish priorities before diving into the housing market. It's crucial to identify needs versus wants, understanding where you're willing to compromise and where you're not.

1. Establish Priorities: Clearly define your priorities and deal-breakers ahead of your home search.
2. Focus on the Right Things: Concentrate on aspects like location and layout, recognizing that certain features can be updated, but fundamental elements remain.

3. Hidden Costs: Determine the hidden costs of maintaining the home to ensure financial feasibility. Avoid unnecessary risks, such as waiving inspections, as unforeseen repairs and maintenance can be costly.

4. Seek Expert Guidance: Rely on an experienced real estate agent as a sounding board to help identify potential red flags and keep you grounded.

Dealing with Homebuyer's Remorse

For those grappling with regret, it's crucial to recognize that not every home has to be a forever home. Selling or renting out the property is an option, and renovations can be considered to better suit your needs.

1. Sell or Rent: If your home doesn't meet your needs, selling or renting it out is a viable option. Not every home is meant to be a forever home.

2. Renovations: Consider renovations to align the home with your preferences. Explore potential tax credits or rebates for energy-efficient improvements.

Today's Market Is More Favorable

The good news for potential buyers is that the housing market has cooled substantially, a trend that began late spring of 2022 and continued through 2023. This has presented a slower paced and more balanced landscape. It is still a sellers market, but the needle as moved more towards equilibrium allowing homebuyers to have more options and breathing room to make educated decisions.

The silver lining for buyers is that they faced much less competition in last year and that is likely to be the trend for much of this year. Unless rates drop to the low 6's or below, buyers are probably not going to get into a heated bidding war, they're going to have more options to choose from and more favorable opportunities.

Key Takeaway

Approach homeownership with careful consideration, emphasizing research, priorities, and expert guidance. By learning from the experiences of pandemic buyers and staying informed about the current market dynamics, individuals can navigate the path to homeownership more successfully and avoid the pitfalls of regret.

Work With Me

With over nine years of full-time experience and more than $114 million in sales across the greater Bay Area, I work tirelessly to be a well-regarded agent, industry innovator, and ambassador for my clients.

Follow On Instagram